When I meet with people here in San Diego, whether they’re in La Jolla, Rancho Bernardo, or East County, one of the first questions I hear is: “What kind of financial advisor are you?” It’s a crucial question, and honestly, one that more people should be asking before they trust someone with their financial future.
After over 27 years in this industry, I’ve seen both sides of the financial services world. I’ve witnessed the devastating impact of advisors who prioritize commissions over their clients’ best interests, and I’ve experienced the profound transformation that happens when people work with someone who is legally bound to put them first.
Today, I want to share what I’ve learned about the critical differences between fiduciary financial advisors and traditional financial advisors, and why understanding this distinction could be one of the most important financial decisions you’ll ever make.
Understanding the Fiduciary Standard
Let me start with what many people don’t realize: not all financial advisors are required to act in your best interest.
A fiduciary is a financial professional who is legally and ethically obligated to put your interests ahead of their own. This isn’t just a nice philosophy, it’s a binding legal standard. When you work with a registered fiduciary, you can trust that every recommendation, every strategy, and every financial decision is made with your goals in mind, not their commission check.
At Copia, we are proud fiduciaries. This means that when we sit down together at our San Diego office, everything we discuss is centered around your unique wish list for your financial future. Your dreams become our mission.
Learn more about our fiduciary approach and commitment.
As I explain in my book Retirement By Design, “You need a great professional fiduciary who specializes in retirement income distribution planning. This is critical because your retirement reality will depend on it.”
The Traditional Financial Advisor Model
Traditional financial advisors, on the other hand, typically operate under what’s called a “suitability standard.” This means they only need to recommend products that are suitable for you, not necessarily the best option available.
Let me be clear: I’m not saying all traditional advisors are bad people. Many genuinely want to help their clients. However, the system they work within creates inherent conflicts of interest.
Here’s what I’ve observed throughout my career: traditional advisors often work for large retail investment houses or brokerage firms. Their business model revolves around selling financial products (mutual funds, annuities, insurance policies) and they earn commissions based on what they sell you.
Think about that for a moment. If an advisor earns a higher commission by selling you Product A instead of Product B, which one do you think they’re more likely to recommend? Even if Product B would serve you better?
This is the uncomfortable truth that nobody in the traditional financial services industry wants you to know.
The Real-World Impact of This Difference
I remember sitting with a couple in their early 60s who came to me for a second opinion. They lived in one of San Diego’s beautiful North County communities and had been working with a traditional broker for years. They had accumulated about $800,000 in their retirement accounts and thought they were on track.
When I asked them about their retirement income plan, they looked at me blankly. “Our advisor said we’re doing great. We have almost a million dollars saved!”
But here’s the problem: having money accumulated is very different from having a plan to turn that money into reliable lifetime income. As I discuss in Retirement By Design, “The accumulation phase of building wealth is generally not the hardest part… The problem becomes how to create the income you’ll need from the money you’ve saved.”
Their traditional advisor had never discussed guaranteed income distribution with them. Why? Because he was focused on keeping their money in the market where he could continue collecting management fees, whether they were making money or not.
This is not how a fiduciary operates.
What True Comprehensive Planning Looks Like
At Copia Wealth Management & Insurance Services, our approach is fundamentally different. We don’t just manage your investments. We become your financial partner for life.
A true comprehensive financial planner—a fiduciary—should be assisting you with every financial decision you make. From buying a vehicle to purchasing real estate. From selling your business to choosing the right banks to work with. From managing all types of insurance to projecting the long-term impact of today’s financial decisions.
Discover how we serve as your fiduciary in San Diego.
We need to know how to determine the cause and effect of your financial choices today on your results years from now. We should be able to help guide you on the best income strategies for your retirement, whether that’s next year or 20 years from now.
Here in San Diego, where the cost of living continues to rise—from housing prices in areas like Del Mar and Point Loma to everyday expenses throughout the county—this comprehensive approach is more critical than ever.
The Questions You Should Ask
When you’re evaluating financial advisors in San Diego or anywhere else, here are the essential questions you need to ask:
Are you a fiduciary? This should be your first question. If they hesitate or give you a complicated answer, that’s a red flag.
How do you get paid? Fiduciaries typically work on a fee-only or fee-based structure. Traditional advisors often work on commission. Understanding their compensation helps you understand their incentives.
What is your approach to retirement income planning? As I always say, income is the solution! You need an advisor who specializes in creating guaranteed lifetime income streams, not just accumulating assets.
Do you coordinate with my tax professional and estate planning attorney? Your “money people” should all be talking and strategizing together. If your advisor works in isolation, you’re missing opportunities.
Can you show me my guaranteed income in retirement? If an advisor can’t illustrate exactly where your monthly income will come from throughout retirement, they haven’t done their job.
Why Fiduciary Status Matters More Than Ever
We’re living in unprecedented times. Social Security’s future is uncertain. Traditional pensions have virtually disappeared. Healthcare costs continue to skyrocket. Here in San Diego, we see retirees struggling with expenses that far exceed what they anticipated, from property taxes on Carlsbad homes to the rising cost of quality healthcare at facilities like Scripps or Sharp.
The fear of running out of money in retirement is mounting. In fact, it’s the number one concern people express to me. This is why working with a fiduciary who specializes in retirement income distribution planning is not just important, it’s essential.
You need someone who will tell you the truth about your financial situation, even when it’s uncomfortable. Someone who will push back against Wall Street’s narrative that you just need to “stay in the market” and “ride it out.” Someone who understands that losses hurt you more than gains help you, and who will protect you accordingly.
The Cost of Working with the Wrong Advisor
I’ve met too many people who discovered too late that their advisor wasn’t looking out for them. People who lost 50-65% of their portfolio in 2008 while their advisor collected fees the entire time. People who realized at retirement that their accumulated savings couldn’t generate anywhere near the income they needed.
One gentleman I met in his early 70s had worked with a traditional broker his entire career. He had a risk exposure in his portfolio exceeding 80% and had no idea. When the market corrected, he lost more than half his retirement savings. Could he still retire as planned? Absolutely not. His dream retirement evaporated right in front of his eyes.
This didn’t have to happen. A fiduciary would have conducted a thorough risk analysis, explained his exposure, and helped him make informed decisions aligned with his actual risk tolerance and retirement timeline.
What We Do Differently
Our team’s focus starts with uncovering the hidden costs of doing business with Wall Street, banks, government, and other financial institutions you interact with. We begin right where you are now, wherever that may be.
You will never be told that you did anything wrong. Instead, we ask thought-provoking questions so you can be confident about your financial position today and your future financial success for years to come.
We work with you to design a customized, well-thought-out plan that you thoroughly understand. We emphasize establishing a comprehensive and coordinated approach that enables you to move confidently toward your goals, dreams, and desires.
Our team’s priority is making your wish list a reality. The planning and strategies we create support your unique goals and are in your best interests, not anyone else’s.
The Retirement Income for Life Action Blueprint
One of the tools we’ve developed is what we call the Retirement Income for Life Action Blueprint. This is a visual model showing you a customized set of strategies for achieving your unique financial goals.
This blueprint includes protecting your assets, wealth accumulation strategies, the cause and effect of what these strategies create, tax mitigation approaches, desired income at retirement, and financial and estate planning outcomes. We present this as a one-page summary of your current financial picture, identifying strengths, revealing weaknesses, and delivering clear options as a list of direct actions to accomplish your goals.
We provide mathematical calculations verifying that there’s a more efficient way to accelerate your wealth and accomplish your financial goals. These strategies are designed to create better protection benefits, greater money supply, and improved cash flow efficiency.
Everything is based on your goals from your personal wish list. This is key! Everything must align with your goals. If you have enough money each and every month, you can accomplish all your goals in retirement and live the life you desire and deserve.
Making the Right Choice for Your Future
Here’s what I want you to understand: your financial future is too important to leave up to chance or to trust with someone who has divided loyalties.
The question isn’t really whether you should work with a fiduciary or a traditional advisor. The real question is: do you want someone who is legally bound to put your interests first, or someone who only needs to sell you something “suitable”?
For me, the answer is clear. After helping countless families here in San Diego and across the country achieve financial security, after witnessing both the devastation of poor planning and the transformation of comprehensive planning, I can tell you with absolute certainty: fiduciary status matters.
Read more about what fiduciary duty means in practice.
But don’t just take my word for it. Do your research. Ask questions. Demand transparency. Your retirement depends on it.
The Time to Act Is Now
As I often tell clients, procrastination is not an option—it’s planning for failure. Every year you wait is a year you’re not gaining the compound returns that could snowball into your abundant retirement. Every year you work with the wrong advisor is a year of potential wealth lost to unnecessary fees, poor tax planning, and misaligned strategies.
Whether you’re in your 30s just starting to think about retirement, your 50s in the final stretch of your working years, or already retired and concerned about making your money last, the time to ensure you’re working with the right type of advisor is now.
Here in San Diego, where we’re blessed with beautiful weather, access to world-class healthcare, and countless opportunities to enjoy retirement. You deserve to have financial peace of mind. You deserve to know that someone is truly looking out for your best interests.
Your Next Step
If you’re questioning whether your current advisor is acting as a fiduciary, or if you’ve never had a truly comprehensive retirement income plan created, I invite you to schedule a time to discuss your complimentary Retirement Income for Life Blueprint with our team.
During this meeting, we’ll review your current financial situation, identify where you may be losing money unnecessarily, and show you what guaranteed income you can expect in retirement. There’s no obligation and no pressure, just honest answers to your questions and clarity about your financial future.
As I wrote in Retirement By Design, “You deserve to have a financial dream team in your corner! This starts with a comprehensive financial planner who makes it easy to understand your financial picture.”
The difference between working with a fiduciary and a traditional advisor could mean the difference between running out of money at age 75 or living comfortably until 100.
It can mean worrying constantly about market fluctuations or sleeping peacefully knowing your income is guaranteed. It can mean leaving your family financially secure or leaving them to struggle.
Which future do you want?
Schedule your free consultation today by calling (619) 640-2622 or by clicking here to receive your complimentary Retirement Income for Life Blueprint.
Based in San Diego, we are more than just advisors; we are your allies in financial planning.
Achieve Security, Empowerment, and Success With Elisabeth Dawson Supporting You!